Addressing Roots of Human Hatred: A Psychological Study on Conformity, Obedience and Behaviour

Posted by Mike Elias on January 16, 2017

Why do troubled times so often bring out hatred in humanity?  In both Canada and the United States over the past few years there has been much xenophobic rhetoric spread around in light of numerous global crises. During the 2015 Canadian and 2016 American elections we saw candidates in both countries “other” identifiable or vulnerable members of society using hateful language and often using them as scapegoats for social and economic problems, all while claiming to speak for the will of those they purport to be the “silent majority”. Furthermore, we saw large groups joining the “unsilent majority” through the use of social media to spread hate, join xenophobic movements and rallies, commit hate crimes and even acts of violence. Those who criticized this movement drew many parallels between the social climate and dialogue of today to that of Nazi Germany. As educators we felt it necessary to attempt to address this recurring phenomenon.

Designing a Unit to Address Contemporary Phenomena and Questions of Individual Choice

We chose to use this opportunity to investigate this phenomenon and its history with our grade 11 HSP3U/C classes (Grade 11 Anthropology, Psychology and Sociology), through the lens of social psychology.  The HSP3U/C course focuses on exploring the human condition on both the micro and macro level where identity and social interactions themes permeate all topics (see previous blog on Language Loss and Residential Schools through the Anthropological Lens).

We wanted this unit to provide students with an opportunity to gain a deep understanding of the four major theories/concepts of social psychology:

  1. Solomon Asch’s work on group conformity
  2. John Darley and Bibb Letane’s work on bystanders
  3. Philip Zimbardo’s work on conformity based on environment and social role, and
  4. Stanley Milgram’s work on obedience to authority.

We think it is vital for our students to understand that only through understanding our past can we begin to grapple with current issues, and eventually move forward as a society.  Thus we want our students to understand how theoretical frameworks operate through a historical case study: Here it would be that of  Nazi Germany and the Holocaust. Having students examine this historic event helps them better understand the present as a series of choices made by individuals. Using this case study, we ask students to reflect upon the individual motivations of the perpetrators, and seek to understand how upstanders are psychologically distinct from bystanders and perpetrators. With that knowledge, students then attempt to understand how the Holocaust could have happened and how people can do things that go against their own morals and beliefs.  Using the Facing History and Ourselves ebook Holocaust and Human Behaviour and Facing History’s pedagogical approach, we created a five day social psychology investigation case study to help students better understand:

  • The experiments that inform our understanding of and conformity and obedience
  • The psychology of the victim, perpetrator, bystander and upstander
  • The fluidity of these roles and how they exist in society in both extreme and moderate circumstances, and more importantly within their lives and their school environment.  

We have provided a copy of the unit outline here.

The Psychology of Conformity and Obedience: A Holocaust Case Study Unit Plan

We begin the unit with a Facing History activity examining Eve Shalen’s testimony on group belonging. Students joined a value line, contemplating what decisions she would make and then reflect on the social costs of group membership. By using this case study as primer for our topic, students are able to see themselves in the decision Eve made, as it is one that faces them almost every day. This activity is related to Asch’s experiment on conformity to the group, and eventually, to the Holocaust. By using an everyday example here, it make the choices made by the perpetrators of the Holocaust more real, as students can identify with some of the motivating factors. They can see how easy it is to be a perpetrator, and encourages them to grapple with their own personal decisions.

We begin our second class watching the Choosing Cruelty: The Psychology of the Perpetrator to prime students’ learning. Afterwards, students read through a condensed version of Reserve Police Battalion 101  and respond in a silent conversation using the big paper teaching strategy.

Drury 1-1.jpgStudents connect their reactions to the video, as well as learning from the previous day in order to understand the decisions individuals made.  When we did this lesson in our classrooms, our students grappled with the horrendous decisions made, with the reality of group conformity, and strong connections were made to all sources. This was an incredibly authentic learning experience for students. Something that really resonated with students was the conformity and cruelty is usually not one monumental step, but a series of many small steps, establishing a “new normal” again and again. This conclusion was strengthened even further as we examined the bystander effect with Kitty Genovese and John Darley and Bibb Letane’s social psychology experiments. Students were able to expand their knowledge in the reading No Time to Think, as they examined the reality of the role of the bystander, and the impact that bystanders have on continuing the perpetration of violence and hatred. The power of a single voice was a constant refrain as students considered why people chose to remain silent. This connection was extremely powerful as we followed the American 2016 election at the same time, and many contemplated the silence by so many people on key issues such as violence against women, xenophobia and anti-immigration sentiments. Some students voiced that by being bystanders, we risk making this behaviour and rhetoric the “new normal”.

The following day we begin class with two famous quotations: “The only thing necessary for the triumph of evil is for good men to do nothing” from Edmund Burke and "The road to Auschwitz was built by hate, but paved with indifference" from Ian Kershaw. Sometimes the best discussions come when students are moving around, stimulating their brain. With this in mind, we ask students to walk around the classroom, popcorn sharing (at random and in succession) with their peers their personal responses to the quotations. This allows learners to further their analysis and interact with different perspectives. Using their prior knowledge, students are able to make connections to their own lives and experiences, reflecting on inequalities they see daily both at school and in the media. Throughout the rest of this mini unit, we continue to reference these quotations in our class activities as we explore how social psychology can be used to explain the choices made by perpetrators and bystanders during Holocaust. This exploration concludes using the short film “Pigeon” to discuss the fluidity of roles between bystander, victim, perpetrator, and upstander.  

Lastly, we end the unit with a four corners discussion activity. First we ask students to individually create a pie chart and split it up according to which social psychological theory they believe is the most influential in allowing the Holocaust to occur. After this individual reflection, students walk to the corner of the room that reflects their top choice. The ensuing discussion allows students to consolidate and refine their previous learning and understanding around the social forces that influence behaviour particularity to the extreme extents that we the world bore witness to during the Holocaust.

Our hope with this course, and these combination of lessons, is to use the social sciences to help students be critical thinkers about the world around them, to investigate the decisions they make in their own lives, and intentionally choose to be everyday upstanders. Our students are increasingly faced every single day with decisions on how to react to inequalities and injustice. By incorporating the Facing History pedagogy with the social science curriculum, students are able to see their lives reflected in their learning. We have intentionally incorporated opportunities for students at the end of each unit to choose to participate in the world around them, giving them the chance to put to use what they learn.

From Facing History to Committing to Participate

Drury 2-1.jpg

To end our social psychology unit, students made pledges to be upstanders in our school, and tweeted their promises to our school and our board. Students pledged to do things like stand up to bullying, calling out discriminatory words used by their friends and making an inclusive space for all. We were really able to see the impact of this resource in our class and our school.

How do you give students the opportunity to practically act on what they learn in your class?

What chances do you give your students to choose to participate in the world around them?

 

 

Co-Written By: Kristen Drury is a history, social science and ESL teacher with the Peel District School Board. She currently teaches at Glenforest Secondary School. Kristen is passionate about finding ways to help students engage with history and wants them to feel challenged to take action. She strives to find new ways to incorporate inquiry based learning and critical thinking into her teaching practice. Follow her on twitter at @Ms_Drury.

Topics: Choosing to Participate, Holocaust and Human Behavior, Canada, American History, Canadian History, Bystander, current events, Upstander, big paper, CHG, HSP

WELCOME

This is where Canadian Facing History and Ourselves teachers and community members meet to share reflections, scholarship and teaching practices that will inspire, challenge and improve teaching and student learning. Our stories provide a window into diverse Facing History classrooms in Ontario, and invite you into the discussion.

Subscribe to Email Updates

Recent Posts

Posts by Topic

see all